Asymmetric risk measures and tracking models for portfolio optimization under uncertainty

Traditional asset allocation of the Markowitz type defines risk to be the variance of the return, contradicting the common-sense intuition that higher returns should be preferred to lower. An argument of Levy and Markowitz justifies the mean/variance selection criteria by deriving it from a local quadratic approximation to utility functions. We extend the Levy-Markowitz argument to account for asymmetric risk by basing the local approximation on piecewise linear-quadratic risk measures, which can be tuned to express a wide range of preferences and adjusted to reject outliers in the data. The implications of this argument lead us to reject the commonly proposed asymmetric alternatives, the mean/lower partial moment efficient frontiers, in favor of the "risk tolerance" frontier. An alternative model that allows for asymmetry is the tracking model, where a portfolio is sought to reproduce a (possibly) asymmetric distribution at lowest cost. © 1993 J.C. Baltzer AG, Science Publishers.