Optimizing R VM: Allocation removal and path length reduction via interpreter-level specialization

Abstract

The performance of R, a popular data analysis language, was never properly understood. Some claimed their R codes ran as efficiently as any native code, others quoted orders of magnitude slowdown of R codes with respect to equivalent C implementations.We found both claims to be true depending on how an R code is written. This paper introduces a first classification of R programming styles into Type I (looping over data), Type II (vector programming), and Type III (glue codes). The most serious overhead of R are mostly manifested on Type I R codes, whereas many Type III R codes can be quite fast. This paper focuses on improving the performance of Type I R codes. We propose the ORBIT VM, an extension of the GNU R VM, to perform aggressive removal of allocated objects and reduction of instruction path lengths in the GNU R VM via profile-driven specialization techniques. The ORBIT VM is fully compatible with the R language and is purely based on interpreted execution. It is a specialization JIT and runtime focusing on data representation specialization and operation specialization. For our benchmarks of Type I R codes, ORBIT is able to achieve an average of 3.5X speedups over the current release of GNU R VM and outperforms most other R optimization projects that are currently available. Copyright © 2014 by the Association for Computing Machinery, Inc. (ACM).