Evaluating the impact of simultaneous multithreading on network servers using real hardware

Abstract

This paper examines the performance of simultaneous multithreading (SMT) for network servers using actual hardware, multiple network server applications, and several workloads. Using three versions of the Intel Xeon processor with Hyper-Threading, we perform macroscopic analysis as well as microarchitectural measurements to understand the origins of the performance bottlenecks for SMT processors in these environments. The results of our evaluation suggest that the current SMT support in the Xeon is application and workload sensitive, and may not yield significant benefits for network servers. In general, we find that enabling SMT on real hardware usually produces only slight performance gains, and can sometimes lead to performance loss. In the uniprocessor case, previous studies appear to have neglected the OS overhead in switching from a uniprocessor kernel to an SMT-enabled kernel. The performance loss associated with such support is comparable to the gains provided by SMT. In the 2-way multiprocessor case, the higher number of memory references from SMT often causes the memory system to become the bottleneck, offsetting any processor utilization gains. This effect is compounded by the growing gap between processor speeds and memory latency. In trying to understand the large gains shown by simulation studies, we find that while the general trends for microarchitectural behavior agree with real hardware, differences in sizing assumptions and performance models yield much more optimistic benefits for SMT than we observe. Copyright 2005 ACM.