An evaluation of feature sets and sampling techniques for de-identification of medical records

Abstract

De-identification of text medical records is of critical importance in any health informatics system in order to facilitate research and sharing of medical records. While statistical learning based techniques have shown promising results for de-identification purposes, few such systems are publicly available. It remains a challenge for practitioners to build an accurate and efficient system as it involves a significant amount of feature engineering, i.e. creation and examination of new features used in the system. A comprehensive evaluation is needed to thoroughly understand the effects of different feature sets and potential impacts of sampling and their trade-offs between the often conflicting goals of precision (or positive predictive value), recall (or sensitivity), and efficiency. In this paper, we present the Health Information DE-identification (HIDE) framework and evaluate the open- source software. We present an evaluation of various types of features used in HIDE, and introduce a window sampling technique (only the terms within a specified distance from personal health information are used to train the classifier) and evaluate its effect on both quality and efficiency. Our results show that the context features (previous and next terms) are particularly important and the sampling technique can be used to increase recall with minimal impact on precision. We obtained token-level label precision of 0.967, recall of 0.986 and F-Score of 0.977 when not including true negatives. The overall HIDE system achieves token-level precision of .998, recall of .999, and f-score of .999 on the previous i2b2 challenge task. © 2010 ACM.